Comments on: Indian Music - Where is the original music? http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/ Deep inside........ Deep !!!!!!! Tue, 02 Dec 2008 14:24:10 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.6.5 By: Kapil http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-156477 Kapil Mon, 12 Nov 2007 04:25:35 +0000 http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-156477 I feel the starting part and tune of Rehman's Rubaroo from Rang de Basanti has striking resemblance to and feels inspired from Breakfast at Tiffany of Deep Blue Something. What do you guys says? I feel the starting part and tune of Rehman’s Rubaroo from Rang de Basanti has striking resemblance to and feels inspired from Breakfast at Tiffany of Deep Blue Something. What do you guys says?

]]> By: sij http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-153912 sij Fri, 09 Nov 2007 01:41:41 +0000 http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-153912 all the songs bollywood copy are replicates or attempts to the originals done in arabic. i.e the king amr diab-awedoony - shukriya shukriya, alem alby - raqeeb-wasia jaane, ya ali, khalbeli, thre are many more..lets start off wid ar rahman ji..well he is a master isnt he?..he is inspired NOT by ARABIC music, but the truth is, his music comes from the raggae type arabic genre of music having its routes from algeria called RAI music, the traditional music of algeria. Although he doesnt copy diectly, he ammends and renders it to his style, which he makes it adapt to indian style of music..he can only master this because he is the onli director in the world which occupiess numerous musical instruments. Take a look at cheb khaled, cheb mami's musics and listen and then compare with rahmans earlier tunes 'sapnay' to get an india......he also mizes spanish in with all the tunes..and uses the works of south indian released songs hes done to bollywood, lakeer and saathiya are direct examples..all the songs are the same from both films he made way earilier, alay payuthey and rythm. Secondly majority of indian directors, lol, pritam is an example...copies music directly, whether its the beat, the melody from the kings of arabic music, amr diab, ragheb alamaneh, nancy ajram..if u dont believe me then type in shukriya shukriya and awedoony, type in youtube, ya ali and ya ghali, type in jaine kaise and alem alby....indians r not being inventive enough in music choice...they ruin the suttle, equisite masterpiece of middleastern music...sometimes it works..i must admit jaane kaise worked well..well done full marks to that..however, its not makin agood impression for indian industry of film and music..we need innovation!invention! ok movies like another friend here typed before, mainly all movies bollywood are copied from the south...mani ratnam saathiya, dilse, bombay, although the latter were released at the same times in tamil and hindi, they used the same cast. saathiya was initially alay payuthey wid mathuvan and shalini..priyadarshan films are copies of malayalam mega hits i.e humgama - godfather, dhol - inhariharan nagar, dholi saja ki rakhna - aniyathi praavu, garam massala - boeing boeing, bhool buleiya-manichitrathazhu... all the songs bollywood copy are replicates or attempts to the originals done in arabic. i.e the king amr diab-awedoony - shukriya shukriya, alem alby - raqeeb-wasia jaane, ya ali, khalbeli, thre are many more..lets start off wid ar rahman ji..well he is a master isnt he?..he is inspired NOT by ARABIC music, but the truth is, his music comes from the raggae type arabic genre of music having its routes from algeria called RAI music, the traditional music of algeria. Although he doesnt copy diectly, he ammends and renders it to his style, which he makes it adapt to indian style of music..he can only master this because he is the onli director in the world which occupiess numerous musical instruments. Take a look at cheb khaled, cheb mami’s musics and listen and then compare with rahmans earlier tunes ’sapnay’ to get an india……he also mizes spanish in with all the tunes..and uses the works of south indian released songs hes done to bollywood, lakeer and saathiya are direct examples..all the songs are the same from both films he made way earilier, alay payuthey and rythm.

Secondly majority of indian directors, lol, pritam is an example…copies music directly, whether its the beat, the melody from the kings of arabic music, amr diab, ragheb alamaneh, nancy ajram..if u dont believe me then type in shukriya shukriya and awedoony, type in youtube, ya ali and ya ghali, type in jaine kaise and alem alby….indians r not being inventive enough in music choice…they ruin the suttle, equisite masterpiece of middleastern music…sometimes it works..i must admit jaane kaise worked well..well done full marks to that..however, its not makin agood impression for indian industry of film and music..we need innovation!invention!

ok movies like another friend here typed before, mainly all movies bollywood are copied from the south…mani ratnam saathiya, dilse, bombay, although the latter were released at the same times in tamil and hindi, they used the same cast. saathiya was initially alay payuthey wid mathuvan and shalini..priyadarshan films are copies of malayalam mega hits i.e humgama - godfather, dhol - inhariharan nagar, dholi saja ki rakhna - aniyathi praavu, garam massala - boeing boeing, bhool buleiya-manichitrathazhu…

]]> By: Indian Music Online http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-152323 Indian Music Online Wed, 07 Nov 2007 16:36:45 +0000 http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-152323 Indian music was original only in the 60's. I never came across anything original music after that Indian music was original only in the 60’s. I never came across anything original music after that

]]> By: chakri http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-109349 chakri Thu, 21 Jun 2007 18:45:26 +0000 http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-109349 is saathiya copied? i dont think its copied. if so which song is copied and can u tell me the original track. is saathiya copied? i dont think its copied. if so which song is copied and can u tell me the original track.

]]> By: rahul http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-98660 rahul Wed, 06 Jun 2007 08:40:37 +0000 http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-98660 <b>Pearl </b> do you know saathiya is actually a tamil movie alaipayuthey ... Well it was by mani ratnam and he had bought the rights for the backstreet boy songs. however rahman didnt agree to use it full and he changed it it was a huge some of money wch was paid by ratnam and in return ratnam sold chaiiya chaiiya ..so i dontt hnk rahman copied in saathiya ! coming to his northern folk music concepts.. he takes the flavor , for example in mangal pandey he took thumbri style for HOLI re and in GURU he took arabic flavor for mayya mayya so taking flaovor is not a COPY ! i dont day rahman is 100% clean , but he is 95% clean and if eh steals he changes it so much that u cant find any similairty ! wat similaiorty abhijjet pointed out is on software loops wch all uses and u hav to have EARS to find them . i prefer rahman to ny oder music director ... he is pretty original in the race of tainted copy cats .. ! Pearl

do you know saathiya is actually a tamil movie alaipayuthey …

Well it was by mani ratnam and he had bought the rights for the backstreet boy songs. however rahman didnt agree to use it full and he changed it

it was a huge some of money wch was paid by ratnam and in return ratnam sold chaiiya chaiiya ..so i dontt hnk rahman copied in saathiya !

coming to his northern folk music concepts.. he takes the flavor , for example in mangal pandey he took thumbri style for HOLI re and in GURU he took arabic flavor for mayya mayya

so taking flaovor is not a COPY !

i dont day rahman is 100% clean , but he is 95% clean and if eh steals he changes it so much that u cant find any similairty ! wat similaiorty abhijjet pointed out is on software loops wch all uses and u hav to have EARS to find them .

i prefer rahman to ny oder music director … he is pretty original in the race of tainted copy cats .. !

]]> By: Pearl http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-24735 Pearl Thu, 11 Jan 2007 16:47:29 +0000 http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-24735 I think Vishal Bhardwaj is original. A.R. Rahman copies too, copies from northern folk music and Arabian songs. But he has put them with too much flavor and they sound so wonderful. I like Ismail Darbar too. I think Vishal Bhardwaj is original. A.R. Rahman
copies too, copies from northern folk music and
Arabian songs. But he has put them with too much
flavor and they sound so wonderful.

I like Ismail Darbar too.

]]> By: Pearl http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-14835 Pearl Fri, 27 Oct 2006 09:52:25 +0000 http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-14835 Thanks for the article. Yes, most of the music Composers today copy music from others. Sometimes, they don't copy it still somebody complaints about it. A.R. Rehman is no exception. He also copies. May not be the song directly but mixing. His Saathiya was a copy, heard about it ? Anyway, Yr blog looks nice. Keep it up. Pearl Thanks for the article. Yes, most of the music
Composers today copy music from others.
Sometimes, they don’t copy it still somebody
complaints about it. A.R. Rehman is no exception.
He also copies. May not be the song directly but
mixing. His Saathiya was a copy, heard about it ?

Anyway, Yr blog looks nice. Keep it up.
Pearl

]]> By: jenna http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-13256 jenna Sun, 08 Oct 2006 01:52:57 +0000 http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-13256 um hi deep i need help im tryin to find indians family system i need the info i dont no where i could find it can u plz help me i tryed every thing i could posible do but i no im not doin the web sit write um hi deep i need help im tryin to find indians family system i need the info i dont no where i could find it can u plz help me i tryed every thing i could posible do but i no im not doin the web sit write

]]> By: jenna http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-13050 jenna Wed, 04 Oct 2006 07:48:52 +0000 http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-13050 deep i already found a song the anthem song for india thankx any ways u realy helped alot thanks i will go on this web site if i need more help ill ask use pplz well bye for now thankz for the help deep i already found a song the anthem song for india thankx any ways u realy helped alot thanks i will go on this web site if i need more help ill ask use pplz well bye for now thankz for the help

]]> By: jenna http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-12981 jenna Tue, 03 Oct 2006 06:06:57 +0000 http://www.whoisdeep.com/2006/05/10/indian-music-where-is-the-original-music/#comment-12981 thankx deep sry for late notiset so how can i find indian songs ive been seraching for them and i cant seem to find them do u no any web site thankx alot thankx deep sry for late notiset so how can i find indian songs ive been seraching for them and i cant seem to find them do u no any web site thankx alot

]]>